Madden Monday: Two Steelers Draft Picks to Love, and One That Was a Wasted Pick

The Pittsburgh Steelers’ draft is always a hot topic, generating passionate debates among fans and analysts alike. This Madden Monday, we’re diving deep into the 2023 draft class, examining three picks in particular: two that show immense promise and one that, frankly, looks like a missed opportunity. Using Madden NFL 24 simulations and film study, we’ll break down why.

The Gems: Broderick Jones and Joey Porter Jr.

The Steelers’ first-round selection of Broderick Jones, the offensive tackle from Georgia, was met with a mix of excitement and skepticism. Some questioned the need for another tackle so early, given the presence of Dan Moore Jr. However, initial impressions from Madden simulations suggest Jones possesses exceptional potential. His impressive size and athleticism translate seamlessly into the virtual world. In simulated games, Jones displays impressive pass blocking, consistently neutralizing edge rushers and creating clean pockets for Kenny Pickett. His run blocking is equally effective, exhibiting the power and technique to create significant running lanes. Madden’s rating system reflects this, projecting Jones as a top-tier left tackle within two seasons. While real-world performance will ultimately determine his success, early indications are extremely promising.

The second pick worthy of praise is Joey Porter Jr., the cornerback from Penn State and son of former Steelers linebacker Joey Porter. Inherited talent and incredible athleticism are apparent. Madden simulations highlight Porter Jr.’s exceptional coverage skills. He consistently disrupts passing lanes, anticipates routes with uncanny precision, and exhibits the physicality to win jump balls. His aggressive playing style, while sometimes leading to penalties in the simulations, also generates significant turnovers. His high interception rate in Madden translates to a potentially game-changing presence in the Steelers’ secondary. His development in the NFL will undoubtedly be key, but the inherent potential is undeniable. Both Porter Jr. and Jones demonstrate the kind of skill and potential that make them worthwhile investments.

The Wasted Pick: Keeanu Benton

The selection of Keeanu Benton in the third round remains a point of contention among many fans. While Benton is a physically imposing defensive tackle from Wisconsin, his performance in Madden simulations has been underwhelming. His strengths – run stopping ability – don’t translate to consistent impact in the game. He lacks the explosiveness and pass-rushing ability to consistently disrupt opposing offenses. Many fans felt the Steelers could have used this pick to address a more pressing need, such as linebacker or wide receiver. While it’s too early to definitively label Benton a “bust,” his Madden performance, coupled with the team’s other needs, casts significant doubt on the wisdom of this pick. His relatively low overall rating in the game compared to other defensive tackles selected later in the draft further fuels this concern. His production in the virtual world doesn’t match the potential seen in other players selected around the same point, raising questions about his long-term value.

Beyond Madden: Real-World Considerations

It’s crucial to remember that Madden simulations are just one tool for analysis. Real-world performance is dictated by factors beyond what algorithms can predict, including coaching, scheme fit, and injury. However, Madden’s performance metrics provide a useful benchmark for comparing players and assessing their potential. The contrasting performances of Jones and Porter Jr. versus Benton in the simulated environment highlight the differences in potential and justify the differing levels of excitement surrounding these picks. Further evaluation throughout the season will be crucial in determining the accuracy of these initial assessments.

The Verdict

While the Steelers’ draft class still requires time for a definitive judgment, Madden Monday’s initial assessments suggest a mixed bag. Broderick Jones and Joey Porter Jr. showcase the high-upside potential that warrants their early draft positions, while Keeanu Benton’s underwhelming performance raises questions about the value of that pick. Only time will tell how accurate these predictions are, but early impressions offer a compelling narrative for Steelers fans.

Call to Action

What are your thoughts on the Steelers’ 2023 draft class? Share your opinions and predictions in the comments below! Let’s discuss which players you think will exceed expectations and which might disappoint. Do you agree with our Madden Monday assessment? Join the conversation!